Monday, April 12, 2010

Asperger's and criminal responsibility - Commonwealth v. Odgren

"He lost touch with the real world. He did not understand what he was doing and he could not control himself."

-- Jonathan Shapiro, defense attorney
Trial started today in Woburn, Massachusetts, in the case against John Odgren, a teenager who is accused of murdering 15 year old James Alenson three years ago. According to news reports of today's opening statements, Odgren's attorney is arguing an "insanity" defense based on Odgren's having Asperger's Disorder, a form of autism. Unlike some other defendants who have raised a defense based on Asperger's, Odgren had a diagnosis at the time the killing occurred and was a special education student.

Under Massachusetts law, a criminal defendant can be found not criminally responsible by reason of mental illness or mental defect if, at the time of the criminal conduct, he lacks substantial capacity either to appreciate the criminality of his conduct or to conform his conduct to the requirements of the law. Commonwealth v. McHoul, 226 N.E.2d 556, 557-58 (1967).

This is exactly what Odgren's attorney is arguing when he says that Odgren didn't understand what he was doing and couldn't control himself.

From today's Boston Globe article:
In his opening statement at Odgren's first degree murder trial, attorney Jonathan Shapiro said Odgren's mind was broken when he stabbed 15-year-old James F. Alenson inside Lincoln Sudbury Regional High School without provocation.

"He began to think that something cataclysmic was going to happen to him,'' Shapiro said of Odgren, who was then 16 years old. "He lost touch with the real world. He did not understand what he was doing and he could not control himself.''
Another account reports that Odgren's attorney described him as "consumed with his delusion" and living in a fantasy world of violent video games and Stephen King novels.

What do people with Asperger's think about using the diagnosis to support an "insanity" defense? Some don't like it. Ari Ne'eman of the Autistic Self-Advocacy Network, one of President Obama's appointees to the National Council on Disabilities, is against it. In a post on the Neurodiversity.com Blog in 2006, Ne'eman wrote:
Returning to the real world, the last few years have seen an unfortunate tendency whereby Asperger’s has been claimed as a legal defense for everything from parole violations to vandalism and assault. Making that argument is not only legally and medically iffy, but also highly damaging to the advocacy of neurological diversity in general. To be recognized as equal to the neurotypical population we must shoulder the same responsibilities. If Asperger’s is a justifiable excuse for criminal action, what right do we have to demand an equal place in a society of law-abiding human beings?
Writing about the Odgren case, blogger Autistic Bitch From Hell characterizes the "Asperger Defense" as a bigoted stereotype, and blogger Harry Williams of The New Republic says, "lock him up and throw away the key." [EDIT: Harry Williams, in a comment below, explains that this is not really his opinion.]

There is a legitimate concern that the use of the "Asperger Defense" creates a false impression that people with autistic spectrum disorders tend to be violent criminals. But this doesn't mean that a defendant's autistic spectrum condition could never absolve him of criminal responsibility. The case of William Cottrell is a good example. Cottrell was involved with a group of so-called eco-terrorists who burned up a bunch of SUV's at car dealerships. He was convicted of arson and conspiracy to commit arson. A federal appeals court overturned his arson conviction because the trial judge excluded evidence that Cottrell had Asperger's. Because the arson conviction could have been based on a theory of aiding and abetting, a specific intent crime, the Ninth Circuit held that the exclusion of the evidence was error. "To the extent that the Asperger’s evidence was aimed at defeating an inference of Cottrell’s intent from the circumstances, it was relevant and could have assisted the jury’s determination of whether Cottrell had the specific intent required for aiding and abetting. The exclusion of that evidence was thus an abuse of discretion." United States v. Cottrell, No. 05-50307 (9th Cir. Sept. 8, 2009).

Because of the same issue of inferring intent from conduct, the Supreme Court of New Jersey overturned the conviction of piano teacher Franklin "Jack" Burr for child molestation. In that case, the prosecution argued that when Burr allowed students to sit on his lap, it was the "grooming" behavior of a sexual predator. The trial court excluded evidence that Burr had Asperger's. The New Jersey Supreme Court reversed the conviction because the excluded evidence could have explained "how defendant’s actions in allowing children to sit on his lap might have been innocent of a nefarious purpose, and to show that defendant might not have understood that his conduct could have been perceived as socially unacceptable." Furthermore, "the evidence would have educated the jury about oddities in behavior that defendant might exhibit in court, and it might have persuaded defendant to testify, knowing that the jury would not be inexplicably alienated by his odd behaviors." State v. Burr, 195 N.J. 119, 948 A.2d 627 (2008).

Evidence of a defendant's autistic spectrum condition in a criminal case can be relevant and doesn't always involve an all-or-nothing consideration of whether autism should be equated with violence or criminality. When you're asking a jury to draw a conclusion that when a person does this, he intends that, it's unfair not to tell the jury if the person's neurology might make that inference a faulty one.

In Odgren's case, I think he would have a hard time persuading the jury that, when he stabbed James Allenson in the heart, he lacked the substantial capacity to appreciate the criminality of his conduct or to conform his conduct to the requirements of the law simply because he has Asperger's. However, Odgren also expects to show that he has ADHD, depression, anxiety and possibly bipolar disorder. Could there be a combination of his cognitive functioning and circumstances that would result in his not understanding what he was doing, or his being unable to control his actions?

39 comments:

  1. Ah Hum... Socrates says "Lock Him up and Throw Away the Key".

    Harry says let the criminal justice system and the jury decide what to do with him.

    If you cannot differentiate between me as a person and a fictional character I created to engage in iconoclastic rhetoric, please stop visiting the New Republic.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for your comment, Harry. I had no idea that the views expressed on The New Republic blog are not your own, but rather the fictitious opinions of a literary persona and sometime remote-controlled attack vehicle. Good to know.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I take it all back. Socrates has taken over my life. Please have him shot on sight.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I had a stepson that through my research, discovered he has Asperger's, he has aggression, but only towards smaller or weaker people.
    During my divorce trial, we (my attorney) and I showed how his neurological disorder makes him unsafe around my daughter. I was able to put in place prohibitions against him being around my daughter unsupervised without an approved by me adult when he visits with my ex wife. He is dangerous and should be put away. He rminds me of this Odgren kid. VERY DANGEROUS

    ReplyDelete
  5. I know this if off topic but I'm looking into starting
    my own weblog and was wondering what all is needed to get set up?
    I'm assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny?
    I'm not very internet smart so I'm not 100% sure. Any recommendations
    or advice would be greatly appreciated. Thank you

    Here is my blog: enzymes digestion

    ReplyDelete
  6. replica hermes watches
    There is certainly a lot to learn about this topic.
    I love all the points you have made.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I know this if off topic but I'm looking into starting my own blog and was wondering what
    all is needed to get set up? I'm assuming having a blog like yours would cost
    a pretty penny? I'm not very web savvy so I'm not 100% positive.
    Any recommendations or advice would be greatly
    appreciated. Cheers

    Feel free to surf to my webpage how to get bitcoins with cash

    ReplyDelete
  8. chanel bags outlet
    Heya i'm for the first time here. I found this board and I find It really useful & it helped me out much.
    I hope to give something back and aid others like you aided me.

    ReplyDelete
  9. My point is, there are other shows that may compete with
    Grey's hotness; it is, of course, entirely subjective anyway (maybe you
    find the cast of. A lot of my students have been extremely successful.

    There is a treasure trove of exclusive tranny porn movies that
    the T-Girl Network provides it members.

    my web blog ... hot chicks

    ReplyDelete
  10. It's very simple to find out any matter oon net
    as compared to textbooks, as I found this article at this site.



    Here is my blog; Somerville dui law firm

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi to every one, the contents existing at this website are truly awesome for people experience,
    well, keep up the nice work fellows.

    My webpage: bellagenix complaints

    ReplyDelete
  12. The dedicated team of AVG professionals can be acquired here all round the time, whom you'll be able to reach by
    calling around the AVG tech support number.
    An HVAC repair company is most often started by
    the technician who has learned the trade through previous employment.
    Donnie Jonston is the author of this short article
    about how you can make money on Ebay Donnie has years of work experience like a writer and in addition working with drop shippers in the variety of
    entrepreneurial ventures.

    my webpage :: Pozycjonowanie w Chojnicach

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks for sharing your thoughts about brows professionally shaped.
    Regards

    My site; skin care products for men

    ReplyDelete
  14. wonderful points altogether, you simply received a new reader.
    What might you recommend about your put up that you just made a few days
    in the past? Any positive?

    Also visit my homepage; Bellagenix REview

    ReplyDelete
  15. My family members always say that I am killing my time here at
    net, except I know I am getting familiarity daily by reading such nide articles or reviews.


    My webpage - dungeon hunter 4gem hack apk, ,

    ReplyDelete
  16. I just could not go away your site prior to suggesting that I actually loved the usual info an individual supply
    for your visitors? Is going to be again continuously in order to check out
    new posts

    Here is my webpage - Garcinia cambogia Plus (Arffcanada.com)

    ReplyDelete
  17. My spouse and I stumble over here from a different web address and thought
    I might check things out. I like what I ssee so
    i am just following you. Look forward to goinmg over your web page for a ssecond time.


    Feel free to surf to my site; Minneapolis child support lawyers in michigan

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hurrah! In the end I got a blog from where I know how
    to truly take useful data regarding my study and knowledge.


    Review my weblog ... jeux casino (www.articleonarticle.com)

    ReplyDelete
  19. As the admin of this web page is working, no hesitation very
    soon it will be renowned, due to its quality contents.

    Look at my blog post; Houston SEo Companies

    ReplyDelete
  20. fantastic points altogether, you simply gained a new reader.
    What may you recommend in regards to your post that you simply made a few days ago?
    Any certain?

    Visit my blog post; Nike Free 4.0 Homme

    ReplyDelete
  21. What's up to all, the contents present at this site are actually awesome for people experience,
    well, keep up the good work fellows.

    my web page ... webpage - -

    ReplyDelete
  22. It's amazing for me to have a site, which is good designed for my experience.
    thanks admin

    Feel free to visit my web site; web site ()

    ReplyDelete
  23. This is a great tip especially to those fresh to the
    blogosphere. Brief but very precise info… Thanks for sharing this one.

    A must read post!

    My web-site :: chaturbate token generator [http://www.sakitkepala.org/UserProfile/tabid/57/userId/42921/Default.aspx]

    ReplyDelete
  24. However, the company's plundering results in Europe have
    experienced automobile with start/stop. In 1932with the Model PB, the company plans to launch the
    Alto Ecoo on the 4th of March,2013 globally. You have to buyy yet
    another car part. Auction sites might offer the
    ability to playback different formats such as mp4, wma, for example, is a
    rather great likelihood that you would normally to get
    a better deal. The engine is compact, lightweight and powerful and
    is powered by compressed air from two compressed air tanks.


    My blog - auta - megalith.fr.nf,

    ReplyDelete
  25. I'm gone to inform my little brother, that he should also go to see this web
    site on regular basis to obtain updated from most up-to-date news update.


    Have a look at my page: jungle heat diamondhack

    ReplyDelete
  26. 00 or less) but it's WELL worth its value considering the
    thought that you might lose your blog otherwise. More it extends numerous opportunities where
    your firm is at comfort and rest assured of no risks & errors.
    Blogging is becoming extremely popular now days where people make
    blogs to talk about different topics, such as politics, word peace, technology, economics, social causes, entertainment, travels, dating and
    so on as well as celebrities create blogs which enable
    them to come in direct contact with their fans and almost
    each and every thing taking place in the planet around you is blogged about.


    Feel free to visit my webpage; WordPress hosting

    ReplyDelete
  27. Howdy! Would you mind if I share your blog with my myspace group?
    There's a lot of folks that I think would
    really appreciate your content. Please let me know.
    Many thanks

    Look at my web-site - where to get garcinia cambogia extract

    ReplyDelete
  28. Hey there! Would you mind if I share your blog with my zynga group?

    There's a lot of folks that I think would really enjoy your content.
    Please let me know. Many thanks

    Check out my blog: aminos

    ReplyDelete
  29. If you desire to get a great deal from this paragraph then you
    have to apply such methods to your won web site.

    Check out my blog post :: anti aging supplement

    ReplyDelete
  30. Very good info. Lucky me I discovered your site by accident (stumbleupon).
    I have book marked it for later!

    Also visit my web page :: weight loss -ebooks

    ReplyDelete
  31. The DVR enabled DISH receivers allow you to record the episodes for later references.
    s, the gardening sector remained strong as people turned to the simple
    satisfaction of home growing, coupled with the produce of cheap, healthy vegetables.
    If you have a vegetable garden that includes growing cabbage and
    tomatoes, you can shred the tough stems in the garden shredder so they decompose quicker than normal.


    Take a look at my site ... Calgary Real Estate Listings

    ReplyDelete
  32. magnificent publish, very informative. I wonder why the other specialists of this sector do not
    understand this. You must continue your writing. I am sure, you have a huge readers' base already!



    Also visit my page forskolin 50 (http://www.ad2post.com/author/lichristma/)

    ReplyDelete
  33. I'm really loving the theme/design of your site.
    Do you ever run into any web browser compatibility issues?
    A small number of my blog visitors have complained
    about my website not working correctly in Explorer but looks great in Opera.
    Do you have any solutions to help fix this problem?


    Have a look at my web page: dinner plates with grape patterns

    ReplyDelete
  34. There are some really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike additional blogs I have read which are really not good. I also found your posts very interesting. In fact after reading, I had to go show it to my friend and he enjoyed it as well!

    Generic Viagra 100mg
    Buy Generic ED Products
    Pharmacy Drop Shipping
    Buy Generic Viagra
    Pharmacy Dropshipper
    Erectile Dysfunction Products Drop shipping
    Worldwide Pharmaceutical Exporter

    ReplyDelete
  35. I am in fact glad to read this website posts which carries tons of valuable data,
    thanks for providing these data.

    my web page; wall covering ideas; ,

    ReplyDelete
  36. This is my first time pay a quick visit at here and i am really pleassant
    to read everthing at one place.

    Here is my blog post ... Swamp Attack Hack (http://Www.Facebook.com/SwampAttackHacks)

    ReplyDelete
  37. Hello, I do believe your website might be
    having web browser compatibility problems. When I take a look at your site in Safari, it looks fine however, when opening in IE, it has some overlapping issues.
    I simply wanted to give you a quick heads up! Aside from that, excellent blog!


    Visit my homepage: ipfna

    ReplyDelete

  38. It is very interesting and informative blog. To Keep your furnace running properly and efficiently, you can get tips or service by visiting at rheemteamcomfort.com

    ReplyDelete
  39. http://www.wirelessforums.org/members/brownjohnn-67869.html
    Purchase Tramadol from our site.We give you best prices and best offers! World wide shipping. Looking for a place to buy Tramadol online ? Tramadol Shop is here for you.

    ReplyDelete