Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Money, happiness and constitutional rights - Matter of Mark C.H.

But for the occasion of the 17-A proceeding belatedly commenced by petitioner, Mark would, most likely, still be an entirely isolated institutional resident. Although his basic needs were met, he lacked the resources to reach his best potential and to thrive — even as significant monies left to care for him increased, unspent in his trust, from which both trustees presumably took their annual commissions.

The facts in this case dramatically demonstrate why a statute that gives a guardian control over the life of a person with mental retardation and/or developmental disabilities must include provision for periodic court review.

-- Hon. Kristin Booth Glen, Surrogate's Court, New York County in
Matter of Mark C.H.

One of the most challenging issues facing parents of developmentally disabled children is how to provide for their care when the parents are gone. In the Mark C.H. case, an adoptive mother made arrangements for her autistic son's care after her death from cancer, leaving several million dollars in trust for him. Because of what happened after the mother's death, Judge Glen of the New York County Surrogate's Court decided that New York's guardianship law puts an unconstitutional restriction on the liberty of mentally retarded and developmentally disabled people unless the court also monitors the activities of the appointed guardians. In the Matter of Mark C.H., 2010 NY Slip Op 20156 (April 21, 2010).

Marie H. was diagnosed with terminal cancer in 2003. She had two adopted boys. One of them, Mark, was autistic. Because she would no longer be able to care for Mark, she put him in an institution. Mark was 14 at the time. Marie died in 2005, leaving $3 million in trust for Mark's care. Marie's attorney was a trustee of Mark's trust, and he made a death-bed promise to Marie that he would also be Mark's personal guardian.

In 2007, four years after Mark and been institutionalized and two years after Marie had passed away, the attorney filed his belated petition to be appointed Mark's guardian under Article 17-A of New York's Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act (SCPA). Under Article 17-A, New York courts can appoint a guardian of the person and/or property of "mentally retarded persons" and "developmentally disabled" persons. In this case, the attorney was to be appointed as guardian of Mark's person only, since his financial affairs were (supposedly) being handled through the trust.

There was a hearing on the petition in October 2008. Mark had been in the institution for five years. The trustees admitted that they had never visited Mark or taken any steps to find out what Mark's needs were, and they had not spent any of Mark's trust funds on his behalf. At the court's direction, the trustees hired a Care Manager, Robin Hoffman, who visited Mark and his caregivers at the institution. This is what the Care Manager learned:

In her interview with Mark's residence manager, Hoffman was informed that

"as far as [the resident manager] knew, Mark [had] not had any visitors in the five years that she had worked with him nor has he had a vacation. She stated that most of the students leave school over Christmas vacation, [but] Mark remains on campus with staff. She reported that Mark would enjoy eating in a restaurant, playing music on a synthesizer, and using a computer. He could benefit from enhanced augmentative communication devices."

In addition to these items and services that would likely improve Mark's quality of life, Hoffman also learned of significant medical issues that could be alleviated by expenditures from the trust.

Judge Glen decided that there was no way she was going to appoint the petitioner as Mark's guardian without requiring regular judicial review of his actions, even though the guardianship statute doesn't require such review. "The facts in this case dramatically demonstrate why a statute that gives a guardian control over the life of a person with mental retardation and/or developmental disabilities must include provision for periodic court review," Judge Glen said in her decision.

Why does the court have the power to make guardians of developmentally disabled wards report to the court when the statute doesn't require it? Because, Judge Glen decided, the statute would otherwise be unconstitutional. Because guardianship is a drastic restraint on a person's constitutional liberty right, due process is required. The guardianship statute, as written, does not provide for any judicial monitoring once the guardian is appointed, thus leaving the ward open to indefinite restrictions on his or her liberty regardless of what the guardian does or whether the guardianship continues to be in the ward's best interest. The judge reasoned that due process requires that the court read into the statute a reporting and review requirement.

Judge Glen also considered the UN's Disability Convention as a reason for imposing reporting and review requirements, even though it hasn't yet been ratified by the US Senate. "[A]s a matter of international human rights law, state interventions, like guardianships, pursuant to parens patriae power, must be subject to periodic review to prevent the abuses which may otherwise flow from the state's grant of power over a person with disabilities such as those covered by SCPA Article 17-A."

As the court noted, New York law regarding other guardianships, including guardianships of the incapacitated elderly or people with mental illness, requires annual reporting and court review, while guardianships of the persons of those with mental retardation and/or developmental disabilities does not. To add this requirement to the MR/DD personal guardianship is not unrealistic, and provides these wards with the same protections that other people under guardianship receive.

According to the Matter of Mark C.H. decision, in practice many parents of kids with developmental disabilities get Article 17-A guardianships over their kids at the point of adulthood, and then the court never hears from them again. If the New York courts start reading the report and review requirements into the guardianship law, these additional requirements may affect familial guardianships as well as non-familial guardianships like the one involved in this case. Although this would place an additional burden on family members who act as guardians, there's no guarantee that a guardian who is related to the ward will not neglect or abuse him. The story of Tiffany Pinckney, who died under her sister's guardianship, is an example. It seems sensible to afford people under MR/DD guardianships the protection of ongoing court supervision to preserve their constitutional and human rights.


  1. Hello! Someone in my Myspace group shared this website with us so
    I came to give it a look. I'm definitely enjoying the information. I'm bookmarking and will be
    tweeting this to my followers! Great blog and excellent design and

    Feel free to visit my blog ... zetaclear nail fungus relief

  2. We absolutely love your blog and find a lot of your post's to be exactly what I'm looking for.
    can you offer guest writers to write content for you personally?
    I wouldn't mind producing a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects you write regarding here. Again, awesome web log!

    Have a look at my web site http://buymiroverve.eklablog.com/

  3. I'd like to find out more? I'd like to find out some
    additional information.

    Here is my web-site :: lovecolombian.com

  4. Its like you learn my thoughts! You seem to
    understand so much about this, like you wrote the guide in it or something.
    I feel that you could do with a few % to drive the message
    home a little bit, but instead of that, this is excellent blog.
    A fantastic read. I'll certainly be back.

    Take a look at my web blog: Buy volume pills

  5. Amazing! Its really awesome article, I have got much clear idea regarding from this piece of writing.

    my website ... is Semenax safe

  6. If you desire to improve your know-how just keep visiting this
    website and be updated with the newest gossip posted here.

    Feel free to visit my homepage male enhancement information

  7. Hi there! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and tell you I genuinely
    enjoy reading through your blog posts. Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that go over the
    same subjects? Thanks a ton!

    My webpage :: guaranteed male enhancement

  8. Do you have a spam problem on this site; I also am a blogger, and I
    was wondering your situation; we have created some nice procedures
    and we are looking to trade strategies with others, please
    shoot me an e-mail if interested.

    Take a look at my blog post - hoodia balance

  9. Hurrah, that's what I was looking for, what a information! present here at this web site, thanks admin of this site.

    Also visit my site; alta white

  10. I used to be suggested this website through my cousin.

    I am no longer positive whether this publish is written via him as
    no one else recognise such designated approximately my difficulty.
    You're incredible! Thanks!

    My blog xtreme no

  11. I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme.
    Did you create this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you?
    Plz reply as I'm looking to design my own blog and would like to know where u got this from. kudos

    Look at my web site - does hoodia really work

  12. Really no matter if someone doesn't be aware of after that its up to other viewers that they will help, so here it takes place.

    my web-site: nitric oxide for ed

  13. Hi there just wanted to give you a brief heads up and
    let you know a few of the pictures aren't loading properly. I'm not
    sure why but I think its a linking issue. I've tried it in two different internet browsers and both show the same outcome.

    Also visit my webpage - genf20 plus

  14. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I've really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing for your rss feed and I'm
    hoping you write once more very soon!

    Look into my weblog: sexual performance

  15. I like what you guys are up too. This type of clever
    work and coverage! Keep up the awesome works guys I've included you guys to my blogroll.

    Also visit my blog post - http://kashmir.mindsmiracles.com/

  16. Great site you have here.. It's difficult to find quality writing like yours nowadays. I seriously appreciate people like you! Take care!!

    my homepage ... buy virility ex

  17. Phen375 is a form of Phentermine, that's one from the most popular supplements for weight reduction. Diet pills are just what the name implies "ingredients inside a pill which can be supposed that can assist you slim down" and zilch much more. It also releases chemicals to assist the deteriorating of body fats.

    Feel free to visit my homepage phen375 discount

  18. I just like the valuable info you provide
    for your articles. I will bookmark your weblog and
    test again here frequently. I am reasonably certain I will learn a lot of new stuff right right here!
    Good luck for the following!

    Here is my web-site ... buy meratol

  19. I'm impressed, I must say. Seldom do I encounter a blog that's both educative and amusing,
    and without a doubt, you've hit the nail on the head. The issue is something that too few men and women are speaking intelligently about. I am very happy that I came across this during my search for something relating to this.

    my web page ... where to buy semenax

  20. Simply want to say your article is as astonishing.
    The clarity for your publish is just excellent and i can assume
    you are a professional in this subject. Well with your permission let me to snatch your RSS feed
    to stay updated with impending post. Thank you
    1,000,000 and please keep up the enjoyable

    my website ... acai berry select

  21. Vizio Telly Reviews Enable Simply select the Best Vizio High-definition Tv

    My page; online video to mp3 converter